There is a program on TV Asia that I used to watch and like, 'Abhi to Main Jawan Hoon', presenter is Shiraz Sharif (I think).TV Asia Program
Its a program that plays only very old black and white (melodious) hindi movie songs. Thats good, because we like to watch and enjoy the oldies too. However, the reason I stopped watching this program is that Shiraz sahab wouldn't stop criticizing new music, and always rates old music very highly while putting down the new generation songs. I totally disagree with him, and I don't understand what the point of his program is. Is it to revive old memories or try to convince everyone how terrible the new music is? He brings in interviewees (celebrities from past) and asks, whats the difference between old and new music? And then says repeatedly 'ab woh baat kahan'. sigh sigh.
Of course, music is different now - but its not bad by any means. Whats wrong with today's music? There are some excellent songs nowadays that, honestly, make the oldies seem a bit boring at times. Thats what I think! There is still good poetry, good use of old and new instruments, better production quality and the scope is so much wider, as it includes non-filmi music too.
There was an interview with Javed Akhtar in the same program and I thought Javed A put everything in perspective. Mr Sharif, of course, asked the same question that he often asks, you know difference between old and new shayari.... So Javed A said (not exact words), 'every era makes good and bad music. Its just we only remember the good music from the past so we think that the previous era was better. In old days too there were poor singers, music composers, but nobody remembers THOSE tatpunjeys. Today also there are many good people writing good poetry, and making good music....' I think thats true. And Javed A must be one of them he he.
Also, there are so many legendary music maestros of the old era, like Ustad Amjad Ali Khan, Shiv Kumar Shankar, Pandid Jasraj, Jagjit Singh, who still routinely contribute to contemporary music while keeping their solid and rich classical heritage. So many of them come as special guests/judges at Indian Idol, Sa re ga ma pa TV reality shows. And they can teach the youngsters sooo much! This works great both ways.
Oh, I wanted to mention this too on the side - some of the sa re ga ma pa challenge finalists went to wish Lata Mangeshkar on her b'day at her house. Couple of them sang for her. And she asked, 'can you sing something of your own? It is not wise to just copy other singers - when you are able to sing a composition of your own, then THAT will mean you are a great singer'. Well said, Lata di. Gotta love her!
Getting back to Mr. Sharif - please don't criticize new music anymore. It really hurts. Look at this song and tell me its bad poetry, bad music, haan?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KONhYK391pk&mode=related&search=